Capital punishment is necessary to justify those who violate the law

Conviction and simple imposition of a penalty might themselves be thought to contribute to reform if they help an offender become aware that he has acted wrongly.

Finally, defenders of capital punishment sometimes support their case by citing those convicted offenders -- for example, Gary Gilmore -- who have asked to be executed rather than imprisoned.


The catalogs of beneficial consequences that utilitarians have thought can be realized by punishment have varied, but the following have generally been regarded as most important. George Ryan ordered such a moratoriumnoting that the state had executed 12 people from to but that the death sentences of 13 other people had been overturned in the same period.

Additionally, having a person punished by society provides some measure of revenge for the specific victim of the act. The Bible and Capital Punishment A. Catholic Conference To take a life when a life has been lost is revenge, it is not justice. Society not only has a right to punish a person who deserves punishment, but it has a duty to do so.

It also calls for "vigilance, justice and equity in the criminal justice system," with capital punishment "applied as justly and as fairly as possible without undue delay, without reference to the race, class or status of the guilty. The modem debate over sentencing practices raises a more general theoretical question: The assumption thus far has been that those who impose punishment, and the community at large, perceive circumstances as they really are.

What Does the Bible Say About Capital Punishment and the Death Penalty?

Historically, executions were public events, attended by large crowds, and the mutilated bodies were often displayed until they rotted. Like the deterrence argument for capital punishment, this seems to be the wrong kind of argument. In the case of a woman caught in adultery a capital offenseJesus said to those who wanted to stone her to death, "Let anyone among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.

The crucial inquiry, in any event, is not whether what follows such deviations from the bases for imposing punishment can accurately be called punishment, but whether deviations of this sort can ever be morally justified, a matter analyzed below. Jesus did not "abolish the Law," He fulfilled it, but not in the sense that all laws are wiped from the books.

Go your way, and from now on do not sin again. Is there some vitally important purpose of the state or some fundamental right of persons which cannot be secured without executing convicts? The original Hebrew word ratsach, translated as "kill" or "murder" could refer to either killing in general or unlawful killing murder.

Punishment is imposed by people who have authority to do so—authority conferred by legal rule, associational standard, or social morality. We cannot teach that killing is wrong by killing. If the purpose of punishment were truly to redress moral guilt, justifying this variance in treatment would be difficult, but few people believe that a liberal society should make the punishment of all serious moral wrongs its business.

Such a person need not be reformed or deterred, others acting in self-defense should not be deterred, and punishment is much too high a price for a slight addition to the deterrence of those not acting in self-defense.

Although he may be evil in some sense and able to control his actions, his character has been formed by forces outside himself, and that ultimately determines the choices he makes.

Arguments against capital punishment

Expense In the USA capital punishment costs a great deal. Brett Kunkle brettkunkle is the founder and president of MAVENa movement to equip the next generation to know truth, pursue goodness, and create beauty.

Since capital punishment is not operated retributively, it is inappropriate to use retribution to justify capital punishment.

Copyright by the Christian Century Foundation and used by permission. Many of those who believe that inflicting pain on the morally guilty is not worthwhile for its own sake will also conclude that such pain cannot be supported simply because it nullifies some comparative advantage.

But even if this principle is valid, should the judicial branch of our governments be empowered to determine whether individuals deserve to die? Japan and India also have retained the death penalty and carry out executions from time to time.

Given these problems with unalloyed utilitarian theory, some mixture of utilitarian and retributive elements provides the most cogent approach to punishment.The Death Penalty and Human Rights: U.S.

Death Penalty and International Law by Richard C. Dieter, Executive Director, Death Penalty Information Center Vestiges of these practices may continue, but those are aberrations that further underscore the fact that the world has turned against these.

They say that life should be preserved at all costs, and that those who are in favor of capital punishment are the ones who have to justify their position. Every human being is.

CMP Chapter 7 Capital Punishment. STUDY. PLAY. 1. purpose of government is to impose severe penalties on those who violate the law so we don't get back to the "state of nature" - abolitionists think the 2nd is more important because they think executing an innocent person is the worst possible thing that could happen.

Jul 31,  · They say that life should be preserved unless there is a very good reason not to, and that the those who are in favour of capital punishment are the ones who have to justify their position. Top. Capital punishment was written into God’s will for the Jewish nation in the Old Testament.

The death penalty was a viable form of punishment for at least sixteen separate offenses. Some people have misunderstood one of the Ten Commandments which says, “You shall not kill” (Exodus ).

What morally justifies punishment of wrongdoers is that those who break the law (and are properly judged to have done so) deserve to be punished.

The punishment for a particular offense against the law should "fit" the crime.

Capital Punishment: The Question of Justification Download
Capital punishment is necessary to justify those who violate the law
Rated 5/5 based on 44 review